The Pros and Cons of Allowing Pets in Rental Units

One of the most common questions landlords face is: “Should I allow pets in my rental property?” With pet ownership at an all-time high, this decision can make a big difference in how quickly you fill your vacancy—and in how your property is maintained over time.

At RentMor, we’ve rented hundreds of units across Las Vegas, and we know firsthand the benefits and challenges of renting with pets. Here’s what every landlord should consider.

✅ The Pros of Allowing Pets

1. Bigger Tenant Pool: More than 65% of U.S. households own a pet. By saying yes to pets, you automatically expand the number of renters who will consider your property. This often means your unit will rent faster compared to properties with a strict “no pets” policy.

2. Reduced Vacancy Time: A home that sits vacant is a home that costs you money. Since pet-friendly rentals are in high demand, allowing pets can reduce the amount of time your property sits on the market.

3. Higher Tenant Retention: Pet owners tend to stay longer because it’s not always easy to find another rental that will accept their furry family members. This can result in a more stable income and lower turnover costs for you.

❌ The Cons of Allowing Pets

1. Property Damage: Even the best-behaved pets can cause wear and tear—scratched floors, stained carpets, or chewed trim. Sometimes, the cost of damage exceeds the standard deposit.

2. Noise and Complaints: Barking dogs or multiple animals can disturb neighbors and lead to complaints, which may put strain on you as the landlord.

3. Liability Concerns: Some dog breeds are considered high-risk by insurance companies, which can raise premiums or complicate coverage.

⚖️ Finding the Right Balance

For many landlords, the solution isn’t simply “yes” or “no.” It’s about setting clear pet policies that protect your property while attracting qualified tenants. This might include:

Requiring an additional pet deposit or monthly pet rent

Limiting the number, type, or size of pets

Including clear pet-related clauses in the lease agreement

Allowing pets in your rental unit is ultimately a business decision. While pets can increase demand and reduce vacancy time, they can also lead to higher risks and repair costs. With professional property management, you don’t have to navigate this choice alone. 

The Mor Group works with landlords to screen tenants thoroughly, and handle any issues that arise—ensuring your property remains profitable and protected. RentMor can also help you have visibility and lease your property for FREE. 

Visit www.RentMor.com to know more or contact www.theMorGroup.com to get expert knowledge.